Search Results

The Clean Air Act of 1990 requires on-board diagnostics (OED) capabilities on all new vehicles. These diagnostic systems monitor the performance of engine and emission system components and inform the vehicle operator when component or system degradation could significantly impact emissions. Acceptable operation of the monitor requires proper treatment of system variables. Fuel composition is one of many possible variables that must be considered for monitoring components directly in the exhaust stream. Recently, the octane enhancing, emissions reducing additive methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT) was reintroduced into unleaded gasoline in the U.S. Prior to reintroduction, the additive underwent extensive testing to demonstrate that use of MMT does not adversely affect vehicle emissions or the operation of emission systems such as OBD. However, questions have been raised about the influence of the additive on OBD systems.

In July 2002, the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, the Association of International Automobile Manufacturers and the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers Association released the results of a 6-year, two-part vehicle fleet test program to determine the effects of methyl-cyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT®*) on vehicles equipped with state of the art emission control systems. Analysis of the data reports from this study shows that all of the vehicles met applicable emission standards, even though the fleet accumulated mileage under very severe conditions that accelerate degradation of vehicle emission control systems in excess of that expected from actual vehicle mileage. The study also demonstrated that gasoline-containing MMT had no adverse impact on vehicular emission control equipment.

SAE Paper 2002-01-2894 entitled, “The Impact of MMT Gasoline Additive on Exhaust Emissions and Fuel Economy of Low Emission Vehicles (LEV)” presents discussion and conclusions concerning the emissions from vehicles that accumulated mileage on gasoline with and without the fuel additive, methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (or MMT®). Although the authors of the paper express concern about use of MMT®, the data on which the authors rely are consistent with the results and conclusions from prior evaluations of MMT® which have found that MMT® is compatible with effective emission control system operation (1,2,3). All vehicles tested in the study met the emission standards for all pollutants that apply to the test vehicles in-use and analysis of the data show MMT® had no effect on fuel economy.

Extensive vehicle fleet testing has demonstrated that use of MMT can reduce net tailpipe out emissions. The use of fuel containing the octane-enhancing, emission-reducing fuel additive leads to manganese oxide deposits in the vehicle exhaust system. Studies of the physical and chemical effects of manganese oxide deposits on the performance of catalytic converters conclusively demonstrated that MMT does not adversely affect catalytic converters and, in fact, protected the converters from phosphorus and zinc. Despite the overwhelming evidence that MMT is compatible with catalytic converters and vehicle emission control systems, concerns have recently been raised about the effect of manganese oxides on OBD-II catalytic converter monitoring.

The long-term durability of a vehicle's exhaust catalyst is essential for emission control. Catalyst durability can be affected by a variety of factors including engine oil consumption. During normal engine operation, some of the lubricating oil is combusted. The deposition of combustion products from phosphorus containing lubricant additives on the catalyst can adversely affect catalyst durability. In an attempt to minimize the impact of oil consumption on additive performance, engines have been designed to reduce oil consumption and oils are being formulated with lower concentrations of phosphorus compounds. However, these phosphorus compounds protect the engine from excessive wear and cannot be easily removed from lubricant oil due to concerns over engine durability. The use of a phosphorus scavenger is an approach that works together with engine design to minimize catalyst deterioration.