A Comparison of Test-Based and Analytic SEA Models for Vibro-Acoustics of a Light Truck 951329
A number of researchers , have shown that Statistical Energy Analysis provides a useful framework for test-based noise path analysis - as well purely analytical models. This paper describes the results of a comparative study of two such models - an analytic SEA model and a test-based SEA parameter model - for predicting the Noise Reduction performance of a light truck body.
First, the different power balance matrix solutions and SEA subsystem definitions are reviewed. Second the results of the two independent models are compared. For some specific cases of structure-borne noise, the test-based method is shown to be more accurate than the analytic model. Third, means by which individual measured SEA parameters can be integrated into an analytic SEA model are proposed and evaluated. Results indicate that the scope for analytical model improvement, but also highlight the need for more rigorous “consistency” in the way test-based SEA parameters are measured.